buyers have to pony up more money than ever these days
just to land a loan.
Top of Form
NEW YORK (CNNMoney.com) — Are you ready to buy a house in this crazy market? Better bring a boatload of money to the closing.
In a brutal real estate market where all the players want to hedge against the tremendous risks, down payment requirements and up-front fees have soared, shutting many potential home buyers out of the market.
“I have as many people calling me for financing as ever,” said George Hanzimanolis, a Pennsylvania mortgage broker, “but I’m putting less than half of them into loans.”
That’s happening all over the country, and may slow the housing market’s recovery. Indeed, in a Realtor.com survey released today, potential home buyers said high down payments were the second biggest obstacle, after high home prices, to buying a home.
These days, home buyers almost always have to make a substantial down payment, at least 5%, according to Rich Wordman, president of the Florida Association of Mortgage Brokers. The days of no-down loans are over.
In deeply declining markets, lenders are reluctant to issue loans unless borrowers put at least 10% down, he said.
JP Morgan Chase (JPM, Fortune 500), for instance, now asks for a minimum of 10% down in most markets, according to a spokesman, and for 20% in hard-hit areas. In Reno, Nevada, which has been devastated by the housing crisis, the bank requires 25%.
Even bigger jumbos
For expensive homes, the down payments are disproportionately more. Lenders issuing jumbo loans, which are too pricey to be sold to Fannie Mae (FNM, Fortune 500) or Freddie Mac (FRE, Fortune 500) in the secondary market, are asking for at least 20% down, according to Ed Craine, a San Francisco mortgage broker. In the most expensive markets, where jumbo loans are over $729,000, that means a minimum down payment of $148,500.
Higher interest rates on jumbo loans are also making them more expensive than they normally would be – with interest rates a full point to a point and a half higher than non-jumbo loans, said Mike Tacconi, a mortgage advisor with lender CMG Mortgage Services based in San Ramone, Calif.
And buyers purchasing homes for investment purposes are getting clobbered. Lenders are telling them to come up with at least 25% of the purchase price, according to Tacconi – and sometimes as much as 35%, depending on the kind of loan.
“Rents are high where I am,” said Pennsylvania mortgage broker Hanzimanolis, “so people are having trouble saving enough for down payments.”
Those high down payments are being driven in part by the privatemortgage insurance companies, according to Jay Brinkman, chief economist for the Mortgage Bankers Association, which have themselves hiked their down payment requirements. These firms insure loans when borrowers put less than 20% down, making lenders whole when homeowners default.
In the past, these companies, such as MGIC Investment Corp (MTG). and PMI Group (PMI), often guaranteed mortgages when borrowers put no money down. Today they require 5%, 10% in steeply declining markets, according to Jeff Lubar, spokesman for the trade association Mortgage Insurance Companies of America.
In addition, private mortgage insurers are also charging higher insurance rates. Historically, PMI cost about 0.5% of a home’s purchase price. Now, a borrower putting 5% down can pay about 0.75% for the first year.
And although interest rates are relatively low, industry experts say that they’re higher than they should be, thanks to concerns about the solvency of Freddie and Fannie, which buy about half of all outstanding mortgages in the U.S.
The average 30-year, fixed-rate loan carried a 6.37% interest rate last week, according to Freddie Mac, up nearly a point from the year’s low of 5.48% set last January and up from under 6% in late May. At the same time, yields on 10-year treasuries, which mortgage rates usually track, have trended down.
From June 12 to July 10, 10-year treasuries fell from 4.20% to 3.81%, while mortgage rates actually increased, inching up from 6.32% to 6.37%. Borrowers are probably paying at least a half point more than they ordinarily would, according to Keith Gumbinger of HSH Associates, a publisher of loan information.
That’s because the questions surrounding the future of Fannie and Freddie have made the investors who buy their loans – hedge funds, pension funds, and banks– wary. They’re demanding higher interest rates to take on the added risk they perceive.
Freddie and Fannie have also imposing higher up-front fees for riskier borrowers, based on credit scores.
As of June 1, buyers with scores of less than 620 with less than a 30% down payment must pay a fee of 2.75% of mortgage principal, up from 2%. Between a 620 and 640 credit score, borrowers pay 2.5% (up from 1.75%); 640 to 660, 1.75% (1.25%); 660 to 680, 1.25% (0.75%); and 680 to 720, 0.5% (0).
“The fees are costing consumers a considerable amount of money,” said Marc Savitt, a mortgage broker there and current president of the National Association of Mortgage Brokers.
All these added expenses are slowing an already moribund real estate market. That means it’s going to take even longer to get rid of the tremendous inventory of unsold homes, according to the MBA’s Brinkman, especially in areas that were overbuilt during the boom.
Cities hard hit by the housing bust, like North Las Vegas, Stockton, Calif. and Tucson, Ariz, may have to suffer through many more months of stagnant prices and increased foreclosures before they return to better times.
And these higher costs are going to stick around long after housing recovers, according to Brinkman. From now on, they’ll just be the price of doing business.
Remember to visit our corporate blog at
All information is derived from the Palm Beach County Property Appraisers website and the MLS.